This is all I get. Tried using trainer cleaner, then went and cleaned it out manually.
00:37:14: Kingdoms of Amalur: Re-Reckoning, Version cs 7173 (STEAM/ORIGIN)
00:37:17: Successfully attached to koa
00:37:17: Collect Progression, Script error in line 3: Cannot find aob for 'Collect_Progression'
Your game Steam or Origin?
At times, a new game may be needed to resolve failed options if the data in your save file was altered. Use on a new game and test the option. If it now works, quit to main menu and load your save and try it again. May also need to run the game without the trainer first and play a bit so the save file gets updated to use possible new values.
May also need to verify the game files if the Steam Works Common Redistribution did not update correctly.