Super Smash Brothers: Melee Message Board  

roy doesn't scuk even a n00b can play him hes the best.
its marth whos the freakin retard, his shield breaker is crap and he sucks over all he sucks a whole lot in home run derby

I can beat a LV9 Roy with Pichu in a 3-life battle. And I have at least 2 lives left.
I can beat a LV9 Marth with Bowser in a 3-life match, but I only have 1 life left.

Therefore, Marth>>Roy

jman, the debate over superiority is more or less based on personal opinion. Marth is a great fighter and his speed and attacks put him very high in my rankings. However, depending on the battle, he's not necessarily the better of the two. Think about it; if one person is fighting as Bowser and the other is using Pichu, odds are that Bowser would win due to his weight and sheer power. The same goes for all the characters in the game. Each one would fare differently depending on whom their opponent was. So, there are just as many cases in which Roy is better than Marth and vice versa. Even if the battle was between Marth and Roy, the outcome would be based on the skill level of the gamer, not the character stats. That said, I don't take kindly to people calling me a liar.

Towtha: I refuse to stoop to such low levels. If I were to have an immature squabble, it would be between me and a member............too bad, you're just a lowly guest.





[Edited by eternalflame, 3/6/2005 1:25:41 PM]