This is a game I'm more excited to play than Bioshock Infinite, and I was rabid about playing that. This game to me just looks better than Bioshock Infinite, I hope I'm not let down from my high expectations.
Both games have different settings, art styles and themes. You can't really compare them. However I think this game will have more replay value than the other one, cause you can kill enemies using different weapons, combos and locations. Heck you can get by without killing any enemy (so I've heard) [perhaps an achievement will be there for that as well?].
Let's hope this game live up to the hype.