I'd have to agree with HG, there's just something about the old style I preferred. I think the dynamic game images in the header was a big part of that. Maybe it was also the simplification, making it seem less professional to me? But that's just my opinion and I know you want to streamline it. I'll get used to it and I'm sure you aren't entirely finished tweaking it yet.
RTFOPost? Still a couple of weeks before it's fully implemented and then some to tweak based on feedback. Nothing left to do but wait, I guess.
Also, Spike is best pony.