I have to say no. Remakes do not feel the same.
I agree, sometimes they feel much better..
If they only changed the graphics, sure.
In "shadow Warrior" for example I think it's obviously better graphics but also better gameplay and storyline.
On the other hand you got "Duke Nukem" which has also much better graphics but they ruined the gameplay completely...
If they only changed the graphics, sure.
I don't get this fascination with graphics.
They're games, not pictures.
If it's a good game, it doesn't matter if it's monochrome wire-frames.