I think you're confusing No-CD fixes with pirated versions of games. Piracy is a difficult term to define but the best definition that I've come across for it is the unauthorized use of software and/or data without permission nor a license.
A No-CD fix for a game falls under a more general term of things in that it is essentially an unauthorized patch to a game that most commonly removes the requirement to have the game CD/DVD in your CD drive (hence the name No-CD fix) but it is not limited to just this. Some of these fixes do have changes that disable a games protection mechanism and potentially allow someone to bypass product activation (which falls under piracy). For this reason they are in the gray area of legality.
From a CHU perspective, using a No-CD fix is not enough grounds to prove that someone is using it to pirate software and it is usually nearly impossible to prove with concrete evidence that someone is doing so. Note that No-CD fixes are part of the trainer troubleshooting process and that there are links to websites of where to find them in the troubleshooting guide if you want to download and use one to see if it is something in the game's protection mechanisms preventing a trainer from functionality. If you're going to link someone to a No-CD fix, ensure that it contains only the No-CD fix (and this includes the website itself in general. Again you can reference the links in the troubleshooting guide without worry).
If you have to reference you are using a No-CD fix, please ensure you are using a No-CD fix (avoid the terms "crack" or "warez" ) and that it is under the guidance of the troubleshooting guide. This will help establish the reason for more clarity (as well as help with additional troubleshooting options should this fail). In general it is best practice to state the purpose of using a No-CD fix if you're going to mention that you are using one.
Hopefully this clears up any confusion.
[Edited by Neo7, 12/14/2012 9:27:28 PM]
Thank you Neo7. You have hit my point on the head. That is what I was asking about. While I appreciate the prior comments and links that where included the point was missed by the provider.
I mentioned that my state has a law that says using these No-CD fixes or No CD cracks is NOT piracy because what is happening is a modification of software installed on a user's computer. Not the actual proprietary intelectual software that is on the original cd or dvd that the software was installed from. Thus making it legal and in turn not even a violation of exsisting end user license that are included with the software disks.
The fact is the owner of the computer has the right to alter or modify the software they use while it is on their computer under most user licenses as long as any modifications do not occur to the original software. If it was not legal then we would not be able to make and use game mods or even trainers!
With the advent of cd/dvd burners the act of burning a modified copy of the original software to a disk with or without intent to sell or distribute would actually be piracy since it would allow the altered software to be installed on another computer in the modified condition.
So. As long as the NoCD/NoDVD fix or crack is only used on the software installed on the user's machine and not the actual software disk the act is legal and not piracy. It is as you said. A tool that allows gameplay without subjecting the original software disk to excessive wear and possible damage which would or could eventually render the disk unusuable.
Something that has been going on since the advent of CD/DVD disk use. Hince the market for disk resurfacer tools which eventually do more damage than good. Ok.. I think I have rambled on enough for one subject.
Incidently. I have been useing No-CD and No-DVD fixes/cracks for a number of years now and I have never had any issue with any kind of malware or spyware popping up on my computer. Seems having a decent antimalware, an antispyware, and a decent antivirus may be the answer to that issue if it is that big a concern.
Thank you again Neo7!
I'm not a "lawyer" either, but after a bit of research into reputable sources (not game-related ones either). I found this article. Link.
I suppose it is worth noting that I am an InfoSec professional and, in my most humblest of professional opinions, using a no-cd crack is a form of piracy whether intentional or not.
It circumvents the proprietary rights of the software developers and the potential for abuse is too great to warrant the "legitimate" use of these types of things. This doesn't even touch on the whole idea that the people who create these cracks usually bundle malware into the executable hoping that someone uses it.
It's similar to taking a music CD, ripping it to your desktop, making copies on blank discs, and mass-distributing them. Yeah, you did buy the CD, but you really only bought the right to use the songs for personal use. What they don't tell you is that you DID NOT buy exclusive rights to the songs. Same with software like games and the like.
Here's another good article Link
Thank you for your input Wrythe1985. I did a read through of the sites you linked to and found what you are referring to both interesting and confusing since the court case shows a court saying it had to rule one way but apparently not fully aggreing with it and that case as well as others pending are far from over. The first link page was one of those blanket hater type sites by my opionion because the view is clearly against any alteration of software so they included No-CD fixes and cracks claiming that apparently they all allow installation of software and games without having to put in the CD-key to activate the game. I can tell you flat out that as long as I have been using them I have NEVER had any No-CD or No-DVD fix OR CRACK eliminate a CD-Key requirement for activating a game. Even when I could not find the manual for a game I have that required online activation with the key or you could not play the game. I installed it, then without thinking about it, I made my backup of the game execute file so I could restore it for updating the game and then overwrote the ingame execute with the no-cd crack/fix and tried to launch the game. The CD-Key panel came up asking me to input the CD-Key for the game. SO that disproves the first site authors blanket claim that no-cd fixes and cracks allow you to install and bypass activation. It is not true. At least in the one time I happen to try it with no success. About two days later I found the manual. I had restored my game execute and started the game, input my cd-key and have used the game, the no-cd crack, and a game trainer for hours of pleasurable gaming without having to worry about trashing my original game disk. Which is my only real goal for using these tools.
OH.. And yes! I have tried those programs like Game Drive and Virtual Drive. They are supposed to copy the required files from the game disk to an "on your drive" faux cd-drive so that when the game looks for the disk it finds the files it needs in the faux drive... 4 of 5 did not work AT ALL.. The 5th worked for about 30 days and then the game launcher started asking for the disk only to fail to find it even in the drive that the game was installed from originally.
So.. What it really boils down to is "User's Choice" as to if a game user wants to use one of these "tools" so they can play a game without having to put the disk in the drive and risking it getting scratched or skuffed. That would also mean it is the game user's "Choice" if they want to use a trainer to modify the software on their computer so they can enhance their gameplay.
As long as the user does not copy that altered software to a CD-rom or DVD-rom disk where it could be moved to and installed on someone else's computer in the modified state.
Again. Thank you for your input. It was helpful and educational.
To you and yours. Have a safe and happy holiday season.