This topic is exactly what it says, post your favorite weapon from AMA or AMR or both. Personally I have not had a chance to play AMR, but my favorite weapon of AMA was the Ice Wand, with that i'll let this topic take off of it's own accord.
I'm not far into the game yet, but I like the fully upgraded vorpal sword so far. (All I have is the vorpal sword, hobby horse, and pepper grinder, so far, all fully upgraded thanks to the trainer). The hobby horse does major damage but it's too slow for my taste. I need to play American McGee's Alice again. It's been years but I remember it being much "darker" than this version. However, like I said, I'm not very far in Madness Returns.