Terraria's got a lot of item customization and an actual storyline. There are even World Bosses in the game. Overall, it's just a more completed version of minecraft. If Terraria wasn't 2d and was more like Minecraft, I'd never leave it.
Laaaaame. I had a huge project going on in that one. I would have liked to see it completed. I was on two other servers with two different groups of friends, but the same thing happened to them and both servers died. A few of them have moved to Terraria now. I like it, but there's something special about Minecraft, which sucks because Terraria seems to be better in all the other areas expect 3dness.
I just took a final for a History class that covered America's history from 1865 to 1944 and you're really making me want to start watching old war movies.
Also, is the No Newbs Minecraft server still going? It looks like the last post in the forums about it was about a year ago...